Teachers in my experience have never put
much emphasis on revision. If they asked us to do it, it was never looked at as
detrimental. If we didn’t bring a revised copy in, there were no penalties, no
talk of revision, nothing. As a result, many students, like Gallagher
mentioned, simply did a quick spell check and punctuation check. To this day, I
still struggle with revising my own writing. As a future teacher, this gives me
conflicting feelings. If I see the importance of revision and value it in my
classroom, shouldn’t it be a skill I embrace in my writing. It wasn’t until
this course that I have sat down, thought about my writing, and thoroughly
revised it. Gallagher’s section on revision he gives examples of how to model
good, deep revision. One of these strategies is getting students to get rid of
“be” verbs and replacing them with stronger verbs. The example Gallagher gives
is: “The clouds were in the sky” versus “The clouds hung in the sky” (68). The
difference in these two sentences is strong: the later paints a picture while
the former gives a basic statement.
I personally feel that this is an
important skill to learn. The only time a teacher told me this and enforced it
was during my second semester of college. Since then, I have noticed a change
in my papers. I always try to make a point to look through my papers and find
forms of “to be”. If I see them, I try my best to switch them with a stronger,
more descriptive word. If my writing has become stronger from implementing this
strategy, imagine how strong student writing would be if they became familiar
with this strategy during their freshman or sophomore years of high school!
When I have my own classroom, I will make sure I set time aside to teach
revision strategies that develop student writing. Since I do not revise much, I
will use my classroom as an outlet to learn and revise along with my students,
modeling that not one piece of writing is perfect.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think that the example you give is a particularly useful way to show how the most minor revision strategies can sometimes be the most effective. I imagine few students realize the power that can be injected into a piece of writing by changing a verb here and there. I think its important to have these little tips up our sleeves to help out young writers, especially those who lack confidence.
ReplyDeleteI think choosing the right words--nouns and verbs--does create clarity and can affect sentence fluency. But what about deeper revision? Cutting out paragraphs, adding new ones? Releasing chunks of thoughts that may have been necessary to get you started, but are no longer useful?
ReplyDeleteI too think revision is often looked over in the classroom. I know personally revising is something I struggle with greatly. I feel this can be attributed to its underemphasis in my education. Though I am a strong believer in evaluating student s on the content of their writing and not the grammar and mechanics this is still an important skill that teachers should place more focus on. As a future teacher I hope to find engaging and effective methods of revision like some of the ones Gallagher mentions to use in my classroom.
ReplyDelete