I
find the idea that low-income families do not care about education highly
unsettling. Just because a family does not appear at open houses,
parent-teacher conferences, or sit down and help their children with schoolwork
does not make them careless. Likewise, students from poor families do not act
passively in the classroom because they do not care. The home situation for
poor families is just as diverse as wealthier families: some parents work
multiple jobs and are rarely home, some cannot find work, and some speak a
language other than English. As a result, there is some discomfort when they
are asked to enter a school where everyone is “expected” to be white. In other
words, every member of the school community is expected to possess resources
and qualities that could place them in the favored, upper-middle class society.
If a parent does not speak English they may feel targeted and self- conscious
about their abilities to fit into the school community. Their children can also
feel this discomfort around their peers. They may feel uncomfortable talking
about there home lives with those in their class because they, like their
parents, may feel targeted. If they know they are different, why would they
speak up? In regards to their schoolwork, poor students may perform below their
ability because they may have to take care of younger siblings, work after
school, or suffer anxieties about their lives and families.
I agree with Blad’s belief that
“[t]he social and educational inequities in the U.S. must be our targets for
repair – not our students”. The placements we give poor families in our society
disrupts a student’s abilities to learn and make the most out of their
education. Although they have the ability to succeed and do well in school,
environmental factors bring them down. They feel that because they cannot get
out of the rut we put them in, there is no use in excelling in their education;
the opportunities they dream of will never be given to them. As Blad states,
teachers unintentionally demoralize their students by initially giving them
100% on an assignment and them taking points away from them because they did
something wrong. Continuously seeing the evil red pen on a corrected assignment
forces students to believe their differences, i.e. language, resources, etc,
are their enemies, even if they cannot be changed. As a graduate of Classical
High School, which had students of all class and cultural backgrounds, I know
for a fact that very low- income students have the ability to succeed in school
and follow their dreams. As a result, it is the teacher’s job to boost a
student’s morale and embrace their differences.
I agree with you Jenna about the assumptions low income parents not being "involved" in the child's school to be unsettling and overall very unfair. Just because a parent shows up to an open house or conference does not measure how much they care or how much the value education. Ultimately some of these parents would probably love to be more involved in the child's school but their time is prioritized elsewhere in order to support their family in the best way they can.
ReplyDeleteI also thought that the Blad quote you provided is a very important piece of this puzzle. Far too often (in fact, in almost all cases), society tries to treat the symptoms of an issue without getting all the way down to the most basic causes of the problem. In this case, educators who think they're getting to the root of the problem don't realize that it goes down much further. Inequity starts with an individual's actual opportunities to provide for and support themselves and their loved ones. We can't blame parents who simply don't have the time to get as involved as they would like to (because they are hard at work further down on Malsow's hierarchy) never mind a student who is expected to show "grit" and persevere despite not having the same resources that other kids the same age might have.
ReplyDeleteI also found the part about giving students 100% and then taking points away to be very interesting. I had never taken the time to think about how discouraging it can be, especially for disadvantaged students. As someone who fortunately did not have to deal with any insecurities relating to poverty growing up, I just accepted that I made mistakes and needed to have points taken away from me. However, through these articles ,I can now see how someone who (for example) may be an ELL, might find this practice very difficult to accept, especially if the points were taken away for simple spelling or grammar mistakes. Instead of being a learning opportunity to improve their control over the language, it becomes a way of putting them down even more.
ReplyDelete